91ÉçÇű

91ÉçÇű.CA / Faculty of Law / Research / Essay Contests

Nappert Prize in International Arbitration

Made possible by the generosity and vision of Sophie Nappert, BCL’86, LLB’86,Ìęa noted arbitrator in independent practice who is based in London, this essay contest invites participants to submit unpublished papers on commercial arbitration or investment arbitration. The next competition will take place in 2024.

We are pleased to announce the winners of the 10-year anniversary edition of the Nappert Prize in International Arbitration.

Winners:

  • First Prize ($4,000): Sara Nicola D'Sousa (Future Trainee Solicitor, Ropes & Gray; LLM’23 LSE), “The Protection of Crypto-Assets in International Investment Law”
  • Second Prize ($2,000): Kseniia Soloveva (PhD Candidate, Grotius Centre for International Legal Studies, Leiden University; LLM’20 Leiden Law School, Leiden University), “Instrumentalising Nationality of Natural Persons: Legitimate Strategic Planning versus Abuse of Procedural Rights”
  • Third Prize ($1,000): Joseph Ho (JD/BCL Student, 91ÉçÇű; MA’09 JHU), “International Investment Treaty Compliance in Canadian Federalism: A Multi-Dimensional Challenge”

2024 winners

The winners will present their papers at a symposium to be hosted (in person) on 7ÌęOctober 2024 at 91ÉçÇű. The three winners will compete for a $1,000 award for the Best Oralist. To attend the symposium, you can register here:Ìę

Honourable Mentions:

Helin Laufer (PhD in Law Candidate, University of Cambridge), “The applicability of international investment agreements in times of armed conflict”

Dmitrii Shchetinin (PhD Candidate, Erasmus University Rotterdam; LLM’23 HSE, LLM’24 UU), “The Impact of Armed Conflicts on International Commercial Disputes: Evidence from Crimea”

Tobias Traxler (Ph.D. Candidate, European University Institute's Law Department), “Valuation (and) Experts in Investment Treaty Arbitration”

Our Distinguished Jury:

We are immensely grateful to our jury for their careful evaluation of the essay submissions for the prize.

Jonathan Brosseau, DCL Student, 91ÉçÇű Faculty of Law

Juan Felipe Coy Gomez, Associate, PĂ©rez-Llorca

Mariel Dimsey, Partner and Head of Hong Kong Office, CMS

André Guskow Cardoso, Partner, Justen, Pereira, Oliveira & Talamini

Meg Kinnear, Secretary-General, ICSID

Marek Krasula, Direction, Arbitration and ADR, North America, ICC

Aloysius Llamzon, Partner, King & Spalding

Caroline Richard, Partner, Freshfields

We are also grateful to Sophie Nappert, BCL’86, LLB’86, whose generosity and vision have made this prize possible.

Any questions may be directed to Tanya Oberoi at nappertprize.law [at] mcgill.ca or tanya.oberoi [at] mail.mcgill.ca. See the 2024 Call for Essays here.

2022 edition

It is our pleasure to announce the winners of the fifth edition of the competition as selected by the jury:

Winners

  • First Prize ($4,000): Maxence Rivoire (PhD Candidate, Cambridge), “The Law Applicable to the Arbitrability of Registered Industrial Property Rights”
  • Second Prize ($2,000): Priyanshi Vakharia (Staff Attorney, Volterra Fietta, LLM’22 University of Cambridge), “The Trojan Horse in Financial Crisis Sovereign Debt in Investment Treaty Arbitrations”
  • Third Prize ($1,000): Juan Felipe Coy GĂłmez (Lawyer, PĂ©rez-Llorca; LLM'19 King’s College London), “La Tensa RelaciĂłn entre la TransiciĂłn EcolĂłgica y los Derechos del Inversor Extranjero: Implicaciones de las Medidas Protectoras del Medioambiente Sobre la InversiĂłn Extranjera en Sectores Contaminantes”

2022 Winners

The winners will present their papers at a symposium hosted (in-person) at the Faculty of Law, 91ÉçÇű on October 18, 2022 at 5pm. The three winners will compete for a $1,000 award for the Best Oralist. To attend the event, .

Honourable Mentions

  • Galo M. MĂĄrquez Ruiz (lawyer, Creel, GarcĂ­a-CuĂ©llar, Aiza y EnrĂ­quez; LLM’24 QMUL), “A Modern Data Analysis Approach on Abusive and Dissuasive Arbitration Clauses on the International Digital Market”
  • Umika Sharma (PhD Candidate, National University of Singapore; LLM'18 QMUL), “Invisible Inequality: The Lack of Regional Diversity in International Arbitration”
  • Aram Aghababyan (Coordinator, AUA LLM Program ADR Clinic; LLM'21 UVA), “Government Blocking of Social Media Platforms as Expropriation of Contractual Rights”

Our distinguished jury

We are immensely grateful to our jury for their careful evaluation of the essay submissions for the prize.

  • Martin Doe Rodriguez, Senior Counsel, Permanent Court of Arbitration, The Hague
  • Professor Lawrence Boo, Adjunct Professor, National University of Singapore & Head of Chambers, the Arbitration Chambers, Singapore
  • Jonathan Brosseau, Lawyer and PhD Candidate, University of Paris I: PanthĂ©on-Sorbonne, Paris
  • Kyongwha Chung, Counsel, Covington, New York
  • Alexander Fessas, Secretary General, ICC International Court of Arbitration, and Director for ICC Dispute Resolution Services, Paris
  • Meg Kinnear, Secretary-General, International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes, Washington, DC
  • Courtney Lotfi, Counsel, Jones Day, Frankfurt
  • Natalia Marina Zibibbo, Counsel, Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer, New York

Ìę

We are also grateful to Sophie Nappert, BCL’86, LLB’86, whose generosity and vision has made this prize possible.

Any questions may be directed to nappertprize [at] mcgill.ca (Ms. Tanya Oberoi).ÌęSee the 2022 Call for Papers.

2020 edition

We are happy to present the winners of the fourth edition of the competition, as selected by theÌęjury:

Winners

  • First prize (4,000$): Diana Itzel Santana Galindo (lawyer, Mexico; LLM’19 QMUL), “The Role of the Seat in Smart Contract Disputes"
  • Second prize (2,000$): Cara North (Consultant, Lipman Karas; LLM’19 MIDS), “The Erosion of Commercial Law as a Consequence of Arbitration”
  • Third prize (1,000$): Juan Felipe Coy GĂłmez (lawyer, Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer; LLM'19 KCL), “El Medioambiente y el Arbitraje Internacional de InversiĂłn: Estado Actual y Propuestas Para la Reforma del Sistema Arbitral en la GestiĂłn de Disputas Medioambientales”

Diana Itzel Santana Galindo, Cara North and Juan Felipe Coy GĂłmez.
Left to right: Diana Itzel Santana Galindo (First prize); Cara North (Second prize); and Juan Felipe Coy GĂłmez (Third prize).

The winners presented their papers at an online symposium hosted by 91ÉçÇű on October 20, 2020. At the symposium, the three winners competed for a $1,000 award for best oralist, which was won by Cara North.

Honourable mentions

  • Harisankar Mahapatra, (LLM’20, Miami), “The Future of Investment Dispute Settlement in the Post-Achmea Era”
  • Mikhail Batsura, (LLM’19, NYU), “Limits to Party Autonomy in Appointing Counsel in International Commercial Arbitration”
  • LĂ©a Deroche, (LLM’20, 91ÉçÇű), “War Clauses In International Investment Law: A Need For Clarity”
  • Eleanor Dennis, (BCL/JD candidate, 91ÉçÇű), “Judicial Consideration of Substantive Invalidity: Understanding the Courts’ Protective Role under the New York Convention and the Model Law”

Our distinguished jury

We are grateful to our jury for their careful and thorough consideration of the essays.

  • Professor Lawrence Boo, Adjunct Professor, National University of Singapore & Bond University
  • Mr Alexander Fessas, Secretary-General & Director of ICC Dispute Resolution Services, International Chamber of Commerce, Paris
  • Professor Fabien GĂ©linas, 91ÉçÇű, Montreal
  • Professor Katia Fach GĂłmez, University of Zaragoza, Spain
  • Mr Diego B. Gosis, Partner, GST LLP, Miami
  • Dr Ridhi Kabra, Associate, Three Crowns LLP, London (winner of the 2014 edition)
  • Ms Meg Kinnear, Secretary-General, International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes, Washington, DC
  • Ms Caline Mouawad, Partner, King & Spalding LLP, New York
  • Professor Marie-Claude Rigaud, University of Montreal

We are also grateful to Sophie Nappert, BCL’86, LLB’86, whose generosity and vision have made this prize possible. The next Nappert Prize competition will be held in 2022.Ìę

Kindly direct any questions to Mr. Lucas Clover Alcolea (nappertprize [at] mcgill.ca). See the 2020 call for papers.

2018 edition

Here are the winners of this third edition of this competition, as selected by the jury:

Winners

  • First Prize ($4,000): Dina Prokic (BCL/LLB’17, 91ÉçÇű; Attorney & Counselor at Law, New York), “SIAC Proposal on Cross-Institution Consolidation Protocol: Can It Be Transplanted into Investment Arbitration?"
  • Second Prize ($2,000): Alastair Simon Chetty (LLB’18, National University of Singapore), “Embracing Practical Solutions in Dealing with the Distinct Shades of Abuse of Process in Investment Arbitration”
  • Third Prize ($1,000): Ella Wisniewski (LLM’17, Humboldt-UniversitĂ€t zu Berlin; Solicitor, Herbert Smith Freehills), “A Changing Climate: The Future of Legitimate Expectations in Energy Investment Disputes”

The winners came to present their papers at a symposium hosted by 91ÉçÇű on November 1, 2018, where MsÌęWisniewski also captured the $1,000 award for best oralist.

Alastair Simon Chetty, Dina Prokic, and Ella Wisniewski
The winners of the 2018 Nappert Essay Prize: Alastair Simon Chetty, Dina Prokic, and Ella Wisniewski.

Our distinguished jury

We are grateful to the jury for its careful and thorough consideration of the essays:

  • Julie BĂ©dard, Partner, Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP, New York & SĂŁo Paulo
  • Professor Lawrence Boo, Adjunct Professor, National University of Singapore & Bond University
  • Professor Olivier Caprasse, Universities of LiĂšge and Brussels, Member of the Brussels Bar
  • Professor Kun Fan, 91ÉçÇű, Montreal
  • JosĂ© Feris, Partner, Squire Patton Boggs, Paris
  • Alexander Fessas, Secretary-General & Director of ICC Dispute Resolution Services, International Chamber of Commerce Court, Paris
  • Meg Kinnear, Secretary-General, International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes, Washington, DC
  • Eduardo Zuleta Jaramillo, Partner, Zuleta Abogados Asociados, Bogota

Honourable mentions

  • David Chriki (LLM'2017, Hebrew University), "SLAPPing Police Powers with Investment Arbitration"
  • Philip Keul (Law Student,Humboldt-UniversitĂ€t zu Berlin), "Security for costs in International Commercial Arbitration"
  • Luigi Pedreschi (PhD Researcher in Law, European University Institute), "Investor-state arbitration under CETA: "FIT" for practice?"
  • Alexey Vyalkov (Associate, Clifford Chance), "The role of equity in the assessment of damages under custom: where are Diallo and The Arctic Sunrise taking the law and are they dangerous for investment treaty arbitration?"

Contest facts

For this edition, we received over 80 submissions from scholars and junior practitioners from (almost) every continent. This was the first year that the Prize accepted papers written in Spanish which, with the existing inclusion of French and English, makes this a trilingual competition! This is a fitting reflection of the diversity and multiculturalism inherent to international arbitration.

See the 2018 call for papers.

2016 edition

The jury has selected the following papers as the winners of this second edition of this competition:

Winners

  • First Prize: Nathan D. Yaffe (JD student, NYU), “Transnational Arbitral Res Judicata”
  • Second Prize: Julia GodolphinÌę (BCL/LLB student, 91ÉçÇű), “Resolution of Tax Disputes in International Arbitration”
  • Third Prize (tie): Jonathan Brosseau-Rioux (LLM student, Cambridge), “The Legal basis for the Application of Domestic law in Investment Arbitration”;
    Bernardo Rohden Pires (LLM student, George Washington School of Law), “Can the MFN Clause in the GATS Serve as a Jurisdictional Gateway?”

The winners will present their papers at the Nappert Symposium on October 19, 2016, at 91ÉçÇű's Faculty of Law. Registration to the symposium is free but mandatory.

The Nappert Prize winners will also have the opportunity to compete for a 1,000$ award to be given to the best oralist by a panel comprised of Professor Andrea K. Bjorklund (91ÉçÇű), the Hon. Pierre Dalphond (Stikeman Elliott), and Professor CĂ©line LĂ©vesque (University of Ottawa).

Our distinguished jury

We are grateful to the jury for its careful and thorough consideration of the essays:

  • SĂ©bastien Besson, Partner, LĂ©vy Kaufmann-Kohler, Geneva
  • Chester Brown, Professor of International Law and International Arbitration, The University of Sydney Faculty of Law
  • JosĂ© Feris, Deputy Secretary-General, ICC International Court of Arbitration, Paris
  • Henry Gao, Associate Professor, Singapore Management University
  • Meg Kinnear, Secretary-General, International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes, Washington, DC
  • Cesar Pereira, Partner, Justen, Pereira, Oliveira, and Talamini, SĂŁo Paolo
  • Abby Cohen Smutny, Partner, White & Case LLP, Washington, DC

Honourable mentions

  • David Isidore Tan (LLM student, NYU), “Enforcing National Court Judgments as Arbitration Awards under the New York Convention”
  • Fortunat Nadima Nadima (BCL/LLB student, 91ÉçÇű), “The Path Towards Transparency Via Domestic freedom of Information Laws”
  • Maria Bhatti, (PhD student, Monash University), “Interest on Arbitral Awards and Sharia”
  • Mevelyn Ong (LLM student, Columbia), “The Interplay of Sovereignty, Personality and Consent in The Execution of Arbitral Awards”
  • Relja Radović (PhD student, University of Luxembourg), “When I Grow Up I’ll Be A Court”
  • Velimic Zivkovic (PhD Student, London School of Economics), “A Holistic Approach to Applicable Law In Investment Arbitration: Reasons, Elements, Goals”

Contest facts

For this edition, we received over 70 submissions from scholars and junior practitioners affiliated with more than 60 institutions, and hailing from places such as Algeria, Argentina, Brazil, Canada, China, India, Italy, Peru, the Philippines, Vietnam, the UK, and the USA.

Most of the applicants were affiliated with institutions in either Europe or North America, and almost a quarter of the submissions were from Asia, more specifically from India and China. Approximately 40% of the authors were women, and the other 60% were men, and most were between 20 and 29 years old.

See the 2016 call for papers.

2014 edition

See the 2014 call for papers and the 2014 winners announcement.

Winners

  • First Prize: Ridhi Kabra (LLM student, Cambridge), “Has Abaclat v. Argentina left the ICSID with a ‘Mass’ive Problem?”
  • Second Prize: Mitchell MoranisÌę (JD student, Harvard), “Between Power and Procedure:Ìę The Changing Balance of Investment Treaty Protections”
  • Third Prize (tie): Antoine Champagne (BCL/LLB student, 91ÉçÇű), “Moral Damages Left in Limbo”;
    Robert Kovacs     (Associate, Linklaters; PhD Student, U. of Geneva), “International Arbitration and Insolvency:Ìę A Question of Applicable Law”.

Andrea Bjorklund; Robert Kovacs; Mitchell Moranis; Ridhi Kabra; Antoine Champagne; Sophie Nappert.
Left to right: Prof. Andrea Bjorklund, Robert Kovacs (tied for third); Mitchell Moranis (second place); Ridhi Kabra (first place); Antoine Champagne (tied for third); and Me Sophie Nappert.

Our distinguished jury

  • George A. Bermann, Jean Monnet Professor of EU Law, Columbia Law School, New York
  • Teresa Cheng, Senior Counsel and Chartered Arbitrator, Des Voeux Chambers, Hong
  • Giuditta Cordero-Moss, Professor, University of Oslo
  • JosĂ© Ricardo Feris, Deputy Secretary General, ICC International Court of Arbitration, Paris
  • Meg Kinnear, Secretary-General, ICSID, Washington DC
  • Philippe Pinsolle, Partner, Quinn Emmanuel, Paris

Honorable mentions

  • Horia Ciurtin (Babes Bolyai University, Romania), “A Hermeneutical Perspective upon the 'Mitigation of Damages' Principle: The Metamorphosis of a Concept in International Law.”
  • Joel Dahlquist (Uppsala University, Sweden), “Beside the Point: On Obiter Dicta in Investment Treaty Arbitration.”
  • Elsa Paparemborde (BCL/LLB student, 91ÉçÇű), “Preventive Requests for the Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards: Toward an Effective Filtering Mechanism under the New York Convention.”
  • Adam Plenkiewicz (BCL/LLB’14, 91ÉçÇű), “Comparing Proximate Causation in International Law.”
  • Fabio Santacroce (Freshfields, Rome), “The emergency arbitrator: a full-fledged arbitrator rendering an enforceable decision?”

Nappert Prize Competition Collection

The ICC, in cooperation with 91ÉçÇű, has released a collection of the best articles written by participants of the 2014 Nappert Prize competition.

Edited by Professor Andrea Bjorklund, holder of the Fortier Chair, the collection is composed of nine articles chosen by experienced practitioners and arbitration experts from the inaugural Nappert Prize Competition in International Arbitration organized by 91ÉçÇű's Faculty of Law in 2014.

Topics covered include:

  • Procedural questions raised by the interface of arbitration with bankruptcy proceedings or mass claims
  • Genesis of substantive law as developed by arbitral tribunals
  • Links between municipal and international law
  • Principle of proximate causation and its transition to international investment arbitration

To find out more, visit

Back to top